@@ -21,24 +21,33 @@ what existing problems does it solve?
21
21
22
22
As you might know, I am working on [ Polyphony] ( https://github.com/polyphony-chat ) , a FO3S
23
23
(Free, Open-Source, * Self-hostable* Software) alternative to Discord, currently still in its infancy
24
- (but growing up by the day!). It quickly became clear that the following were true:
24
+ (but growing up by the day!). Federation is an important topic for self-hostable chat software, and after
25
+ looking into the topic for a bit, the following became clear:
25
26
26
27
- People, especially technical users, * want* federation and decentralization.
27
28
- People, especially non-technical users never want to have to think about federation, how it
28
29
works and what it means.
29
- - No one wants to find themselves at the mercy of one server owner who is responsible for
30
- all their data, even if most don't think about this. This reliance needs to be minimized .
30
+ - People do not want all their stuff to be gone if their home server says "buh-bye" for
31
+ any reason. Account portability is a must .
31
32
32
- !!! info "About AtProto "
33
+ !!! info "About ATProto "
33
34
34
- When I started working on polyproto over a year ago, AtProto was already known to me, but it
35
- was nowhere near as complete as it is now. In fact, one AtProto developer had this to say at
35
+ When I started working on polyproto over a year ago, ATProto was already known to me, but it
36
+ was nowhere near as complete as it is now. In fact, one ATProto developer had this to say at
36
37
that point in time:
37
38
38
39
> I work on Bluesky and helped build the AT Protocol. [...] Bluesky and the AT Proto are in beta.
39
40
The stuff that seems incomplete or poorly documented *is* incomplete and poorly documented.
40
41
41
- Out of all the options, when viewing it from a surface level, polyproto and AtProto do seem sort
42
+ *([source](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35881905))*
43
+
44
+ Out of all the options, when viewing it from a surface level, polyproto and ATProto do seem sort
42
45
of similar. My opinion is, that they try to accomplish similar overall end-goals, but they have
43
46
different ideas on how to get there, making each protocol unique again.
44
- But we'll get to that later, pinkie promise.
47
+ But we'll get to that later, pinkie promise. Also, some[¹](https://dustycloud.org/blog/how-decentralized-is-bluesky/)
48
+ [²](https://dustycloud.org/blog/re-re-bluesky-decentralization/)
49
+ [³](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0wbCctcEIA) might even argue that ATProto isn't
50
+ really decentralized. But
51
+ [that is its own rabbit hole](https://blog.muni.town/atproto-isnt-what-you-think/) entirely.
52
+
53
+ During
0 commit comments